Soft Enamel vs Hard Enamel Pins: What Is the Difference?
What is the difference between soft enamel and hard enamel pins? Soft enamel is a raised, textured finish: the metal lines stand proud and the liquid enamel is baked into the recessed areas, sitting slightly below them. Hard enamel, also called cloisonne, is fired and then polished flat, so the color ends up level with the metal and the surface feels smooth. Everything else follows from those two processes — how each finish feels in the hand, how it takes a Pantone color, how it wears, what it costs next to the other, and which projects each one suits. If you are choosing a finish for an order rather than reading for interest, the enamel pin page compares both finishes on the pin itself and quotes them on the same artwork.
Soft Enamel vs Hard Enamel Pins at a Glance
The table below compares the three color-fill finishes we produce. Cost is shown as a direction only: soft enamel is the most economical of the three, imitation hard enamel sits in the middle, and true hard enamel is the most expensive because of the hand work involved.
| Finish | Surface and feel | Metal lines | Color and Pantone matching | Detail and fine linework | Durability and scratch resistance | Cost direction | Best for | Common pairings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soft enamel | Textured, color recessed below the metal | Raised and clearly visible | Bright colors; Pantone matching available | Strong on detailed artwork and fine lines | Good; the raised metal lines shield the color | Most economical | Promotional pins, events, trade shows, large runs | Epoxy dome, antique plating, butterfly or rubber clutch |
| Hard enamel (cloisonne) | Polished flat, smooth, no recessed feel | Polished level with the color | Rich colors; Pantone matching for enamel fills | Clean color blocks; very fine lines suit photo-etching | Extremely durable, fired color surface | Highest | Premium, retail and collectible pins and coins | Gold or silver plating, rubber clutch, gift box |
| Imitation hard enamel | Smooth and glossy, visually close to hard enamel | Polished level with the color | Brighter and shallower; Pantone matching available | Same artwork as hard enamel | Medium; scratches more easily than hard enamel | Mid-range | Premium look on a tighter budget | Nickel or gold plating, backing card, pouch |
What Is Soft Enamel?
Soft enamel is one of the most common color-filling processes for custom badges, pins, medals and challenge coins. It starts with a metal base that has been stamped, photo-etched, die cast or formed by another metal process. Liquid enamel color is injected into the recessed areas of that base, and the piece is then baked and cured. Because the metal lines stay raised, the cured enamel finishes slightly below them — that is the texture you feel with a fingertip, and it is the single feature that tells a soft enamel pin apart from a hard enamel one.
How Soft Enamel Pins Are Made
- Metal base — the shape is formed by stamping, photo-etching, die casting or another metal process, so the outlines and lettering stand proud of the surface.
- Color filling — liquid enamel is injected into the recessed areas between the metal lines, by hand on detailed artwork.
- Baking and curing — the enamel is baked and cured so the color sets in place.
- Finishing — the enamel surface stays lower than the raised metal lines, which gives soft enamel its textured feel.
What Soft Enamel Is Good At
- Bright, saturated color. Soft enamel takes bright colors, and rich color options and mixed colors are possible.
- Pantone matching. Enamel colors can be matched to Pantone references, so a pin can follow a brand palette.
- Plating freedom. Soft enamel works well with many plating colors, from shiny gold and silver through black nickel to antique finishes.
- Detail at a lower cost. It is a strong choice for detailed designs and promotional pins where the budget has to go a long way.
- Economy. Soft enamel is usually more economical than hard enamel or imitation hard enamel, which is why it is the standard promo pin finish.
Standard production is quoted with up to four enamel colors, and minimum order quantities stay flexible. A clear epoxy dome can be added over soft enamel to give a glossy raised surface and protect the color, although epoxy can yellow over time through oxidation and UV exposure. Many soft enamel pins do not need it at all: the raised metal lines already shield the color, and an epoxy dome flattens the texture that makes the finish distinctive. Used properly, though, a dome can make a soft enamel pin look closer to imitation hard enamel.
What Is Hard Enamel?
Hard enamel is the traditional cloisonne process. It creates a smooth, durable, premium surface that is often compared with porcelain. Color is still filled between raised metal lines, but it is not simply left to dry: each color is filled by hand, fired at high temperature — around 1,472°F (800°C) — and the piece is polished until the enamel sits level with the metal. Firing rather than air-drying is what locks each color in place, so it cannot bleed into its neighbor, and the polished surface has no recessed feel at all.
How Hard Enamel (Cloisonne) Pins Are Made
- Forming the shape — the product shape is stamped or formed from metal, often copper or brass, and the design is pressed into the metal.
- Hand filling — every color is filled by hand into the cavities between the raised metal lines.
- Kiln firing — the piece is baked at high temperature, around 1,472°F (800°C) for a short period, and each color is filled and fired separately so the colors cannot mix.
- Polishing — each piece is polished smooth until the enamel sits level with the metal.
- Plating — a finish such as gold, silver, nickel or another plating is applied.
- Inspection — every piece is checked before packing, because a poor enamel fill cannot be repaired after firing.
What Hard Enamel Is Good At
- A smooth, tile-like surface. There is no recessed feel, and the color and metal read as one level plane.
- An extremely durable color surface. The fired enamel resists the scratching that softer finishes pick up with daily wear.
- A rich, premium appearance. Hard enamel is the finish buyers reach for when the perceived value of the product matters.
- Collector-grade products. It is used for premium challenge coins, high-end badges and pins, collector-grade medals, and premium brand or recognition products.
The trade-off is time and cost. True hard enamel involves more hand work and more steps than any other color-fill finish, so it costs more and takes longer to produce — which is also why only a few factories still offer it. If you are weighing finishes for a large promotional run, that gap usually decides the question on its own.
What Is Imitation Hard Enamel?
Imitation hard enamel is a modern substitute for hard enamel, and it is also called soft cloisonne, synthetic cloisonne or semi-cloisonne. The metal base is stamped or formed, enamel colors are filled into the recessed areas, the surface is polished smooth, and a final plating is applied. The result is a surface that is visually close to hard enamel, usually more affordable than traditional cloisonne, and good for premium-looking badges, coins, pins and medals. Colors can be matched to Pantone references here too.
The compromise is hardness. Imitation hard enamel is not as hard as true hard enamel and its surface can be scratched more easily. So there are really three options rather than two: soft enamel gives you texture and the lowest cost, imitation hard enamel gives you a smooth polished surface for less than true cloisonne, and true hard enamel gives you the kiln-fired, individually polished finish that premium and collector-grade buyers expect.
How to Tell Soft Enamel from Hard Enamel
The quickest test needs no tools. Run a fingertip across the design: if you feel raised ridges with the color sitting lower between them, it is soft enamel; if the surface feels level and continuous, it is hard enamel or imitation hard enamel. A fingernail run across true hard enamel feels almost seamless. On a physical sample you can also compare color height, color depth, hardness and heat resistance:
- Color height. On true hard enamel the color is polished level with the metal line, so the surface feels almost seamless. Imitation comes close, but is rarely perfectly level.
- Color depth. True hard enamel color is darker and less glossy, with crisp, clearly separated boundaries between colors. Soft and imitation enamel look brighter and shinier by comparison.
- Hardness. Hard enamel is stiff and crisp, and resists everyday scratches. A hard blow can still chip or crush it. Imitation enamel scratches more easily.
- Heat resistance. Hard enamel is fired rather than dried, so it tolerates high temperatures. Imitation enamel is not heat resistant and will discolor or deform.
Because true hard enamel takes far longer to make, some suppliers quietly substitute imitation hard enamel and still describe the product as hard enamel. If you are paying for hard enamel, ask for a physical sample and check those four points before you place the bulk order.
Which Should You Choose: Soft Enamel or Hard Enamel?
Choose Soft Enamel If...
- You need promotional pins, event giveaways or trading pins in large quantities.
- The design carries fine detail and lettering that should stay crisp, and you like the dimensional look of raised metal lines.
- The pins will be worn occasionally — lanyards, hats, lapels, badges for a single event or campaign.
- Budget per unit matters and you would rather spend it on quantity, packaging or a second design.
Choose Hard Enamel If...
- The pins are a premium product, retail item or collector's piece, where the finish has to feel expensive in the hand.
- They will be worn daily or handled often, as with long-service or recognition pins, club pins and uniform insignia.
- You are pairing the pin with a gift box, backing card or presentation packaging for a corporate audience.
- The design uses broad, clean color blocks rather than hair-thin lines, which is the shape hard enamel flatters most.
Two adjacent options are worth knowing about. If you want the smooth look without the hard enamel budget, imitation hard enamel is the middle path. If your artwork depends on gradients, photos or full-color graphics that enamel filling cannot reproduce, printed and UV-printed pins are the better tool — our custom enamel pin page covers all of these pin styles side by side, and the die-struck pin guide explains the no-color, all-metal alternative.
Soft Enamel and Hard Enamel on Coins, Medals and Badges
The soft and hard question is not limited to lapel pins. The same two finishes are used on challenge coins and on custom medals, and the decision logic is identical: soft enamel for bright filled color and the best value at volume, hard enamel or cloisonne for a smooth, premium surface on collector and presentation pieces.
On coins, both finishes are usually combined with die casting for heavier 3D coins, die stamping for classic coin effects, and printing where the artwork needs photographic detail. Coin designs commonly add an antique plating, a rope, reeded or diamond-cut edge, and a serial number on limited editions, with the enamel carrying the flag, motto or emblem colors.
On medals, soft enamel remains the popular color-fill choice for race, school and charity awards, while hard enamel and cloisonne are used for collector-grade awards and premium recognition products. Both work on the same medal shapes, including 3D relief, cut-out and spinner designs. For badges, uniform insignia and brand emblems, the same finish logic applies — see our custom badges and emblems range for shapes and backings.
Plating, Backings and Packaging That Pair With Each Finish
Plating choice does a lot of the visual work on both finishes. Common options are gold, silver, nickel, copper, bronze, black nickel, rose gold, and antique gold, silver, bronze or copper, plus dual plating, matte or shiny finishes and sandblasted contrast areas. Antique plating darkens the recessed areas and highlights raised metal detail, which is why it works so well with the raised lines of soft enamel and with 3D relief. One thing to keep in mind when you brief a design: for custom work, enamel color areas can be matched to Pantone references, but plating colors are metal finishes, not Pantone colors. Our plating options page lists them all.
Backings and packaging are where the two finishes separate again in practice. Soft enamel pins are normally shipped on a standard butterfly clutch, which is cost-effective and familiar, and the finish suits bulk promotional packaging such as individual poly bags. Hard enamel pins are more often ordered with a rubber clutch, which is comfortable and common on enamel pins, or with a magnet back for corporate badges and uniforms where fabric should not be pierced. Larger hard enamel pieces can take a safety pin, and formal recognition pins can use a tie tack. On the packaging side, hard enamel pairs naturally with backing cards, velvet pouches, acrylic boxes and gift boxes, because buyers of a premium finish usually want the unboxing to match. Special effects such as glitter enamel, glow-in-the-dark enamel, translucent enamel and epoxy domes can be layered onto either finish — see special effects for medals and coins for what each one does to cost and production time.
Ordering: Proofs, Samples and Production Time
Ordering either finish follows the same path. Send your artwork or even a rough idea, and our design team prepares a design proof showing colors, metal lines, plating and backing; revisions are free before approval. If you are still deciding between soft and hard enamel, ask for samples of both finishes side by side, or a sample so you can feel the difference before the bulk order. Once the proof is approved, hard enamel should be planned with a longer production window than soft enamel, because the firing and individual polishing steps add hand work to every piece. The full sequence is set out in our guide to ordering custom lapel pins.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is soft enamel?
Soft enamel is a color-fill process: liquid enamel is injected into the recessed areas of a metal base, which is then baked and cured. The enamel surface finishes slightly below the raised metal lines, which is why a soft enamel pin feels textured rather than flat.
What is hard enamel?
Hard enamel, also called cloisonne, is fired rather than air-dried. Each color is filled by hand between the raised metal lines, fired at high temperature, and the piece is then polished until the enamel sits level with the metal. The finished surface is smooth, flat and often compared with porcelain.
What's the difference between hard and soft enamel pins?
The difference is the surface. Soft enamel pins keep their raised metal lines with the color sitting below them, so the design has a dimensional, textured feel. Hard enamel pins are polished flat, so the color and the metal are level and the surface is smooth. Hard enamel also takes longer to make and costs more, and it is the more durable of the two.
Is hard enamel the same as cloisonne?
Yes. Cloisonne is the traditional name for the hard enamel process. True hard enamel is filled with vitreous enamel and fired in a kiln, which is why it takes longer to make, costs more than the other finishes, and is produced by only a few factories.
Which is more durable, soft enamel or hard enamel?
Hard enamel is the more durable finish. Its color is fired, so the surface resists everyday scratching better, although a hard blow can still chip or crush it. Soft enamel is still a good wearing option for pins that are worn occasionally, because the raised metal lines shield the color that sits between them.
Which looks more premium, soft enamel or hard enamel?
Hard enamel usually looks more premium, because the polished level surface reads like porcelain and gives a jewelry-style finish. Soft enamel looks brighter and more dimensional. Imitation hard enamel sits between the two: a smooth polished surface for less than true hard enamel.
Can I get both soft enamel and hard enamel pins in the same order?
Yes. We produce soft enamel, imitation hard enamel and true hard enamel in the same factory, so a single order can mix finishes. We can also send both finishes side by side, so you can compare them in your hand before the bulk run.
How can I tell soft enamel from hard enamel by touch?
Run a fingertip across the design. If you feel raised ridges with the color sitting lower between them, it is soft enamel. If the surface feels level and continuous, it is hard enamel or imitation hard enamel. A fingernail run across true hard enamel feels almost seamless.
What is imitation hard enamel?
Imitation hard enamel is a modern substitute for hard enamel, also called soft cloisonne, synthetic cloisonne or semi-cloisonne. The surface is polished smooth and looks close to hard enamel, but it is not as hard, it scratches more easily, and it is usually more affordable than traditional hard enamel.
Next: a price, a date, and a proof
Tell us the quantity, the size and the date you need it. You get a unit price with tooling listed separately, a production date, and a digital proof to approve before the tool is cut.