Die-Struck vs Die-Cast Medals and Coins: Which Process Is Best?
Die-striking and die-casting are two common manufacturing processes for custom medals and challenge coins. Each has its own strengths, and choosing the right one depends on your design, quantity, and budget.
What Is Die-Struck?
Die-striking uses a high-pressure press to stamp a design into a metal blank. A blank piece of metal is placed onto a die and struck with a press, so the metal is compressed into the shape of the die and takes on a raised and recessed design with sharp detail, on one side or both. Die-struck products are often left without color or filled with soft enamel. This process is ideal for classic coins, medals, and pins with flat designs.
Custom die-struck medals can be customized with different designs, shapes, and finishes to create a unique and personalized award or token. The process allows intricate and detailed artwork to be reproduced with a high level of precision, which is why die-struck medals are typically made from brass, copper, or bronze and are a popular choice for recognizing achievements, commemorating events, or honoring someone special.
Die-Struck vs Die-Stamped
Die stamping is a closely related process. The outline of the product is stamped onto a sheet of copper, bronze, or iron — copper is often the better option because it is softer, so the product layout comes out more obvious than on iron. After the shape is cut, the blanks are polished and then electroplated into gold, silver, antique gold, antique silver, and similar finishes. Custom colors are acceptable depending on your design.
What Is Die-Cast?
Die-casting injects molten metal into a mold under pressure. The mold cavity is created using two hardened tool steel dies that have been machined into shape and work similarly to an injection mold. Most die castings are made from non-ferrous metals — specifically zinc, copper, aluminium, magnesium, lead, pewter, and tin-based alloys — and a hot- or cold-chamber machine is used depending on the type of metal being cast.
Die-casting allows for 3D designs, complex shapes, and deeper details than die-striking. The casting equipment and the metal dies represent large capital costs, which tends to limit the process to high-volume production. Manufacture itself is relatively simple, involving only four main steps, which keeps the incremental cost per item low, and die castings are characterized by a very good surface finish and dimensional consistency. Die-casting is commonly used for medals with cutouts, challenge coins with sculptural relief, and products with irregular shapes.
How Each Process Works, Step by Step
The two processes are easiest to tell apart once you picture what physically happens to the metal.
Die casting
A cast is made of your design, then porous metal is poured into the recessed areas of the die. Because the metal flows into the cavity instead of being pressed into shape, die casting reproduces a very high level of detail and captures intricate elements that other processes miss. The piece is then given your chosen finishing option and polished to complete the process.
Die striking
Die striking works the other way round: the metal is struck with the die so your artwork is pressed into the surface. The result is a sharp, crisp medallion that holds its detail well. Die striking is available on iron and on brass — iron is the more affordable choice, while brass is the higher grade metal and gives a cleaner line. If your design depends on bright, vibrant color we recommend iron; otherwise brass is the better choice.
Why Zinc Alloy Is the Standard for Die-Cast Medals
Zinc alloy is an excellent material for 2D and 3D cubic designs that have empty spaces within, for miniature-sized designs, and for designs with mechanical functions such as moving and spinning badges. Because zinc alloy is more economical than brass and has wider application in various situations, it has become the material most often chosen for custom badges and medallions.
Typical zinc alloy material features:
- Density: 6.8×1000 kg/m3
- Low melting point: approximately 385°C
- Largest dimension we can produce: 130×110 mm
- Minimum thickness: 1.2 mm
- Suitable for products that need to be light in weight, and for complicated structures such as solid shapes, large dimensions, or meticulous relief
Comparison Table
| Feature | Die-Struck | Die-Cast |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Flat designs, fine lines | 3D designs, complex shapes |
| Detail level | Excellent for 2D | Excellent for 3D |
| Relief | Flat or shallow relief | Stronger 3D relief |
| Thickness | Thinner products | Thicker products |
| Weight | Heavier, denser | Lighter |
| Common materials | Brass, copper, bronze | Zinc alloy, pewter |
| Mold cost | Lower | Higher |
| Minimum order | Lower | Higher |
| Typical uses | Classic coins, simple medals | 3D challenge coins, shaped medals |
Which Process Should You Choose?
Choose die-striking if your design is primarily 2D with fine text and lines, or if you want a classic metal look. Choose die-casting if your design has 3D elements, complex shapes, or deep relief. For most sports medals and simple designs, die-striking is sufficient. For military challenge coins and commemorative pieces with logos that pop, die-casting is usually better. Because die-casting carries higher tooling and equipment costs, it is best suited to larger production runs.
Typical Applications for Each Process
Die-cast custom medals are the standard choice for thicker, sculpted awards. They are commonly produced for marathon, 5K, 10K, and running medals, as well as soccer, hockey, rowing, biking, tae kwon do, martial arts, wrestling, gymnastics, triathlon, military, and academic events.
Die-struck medals remain the classic choice for flatter designs where fine line work and crisp lettering matter most — traditional challenge coins, simple sports medals, and events where a clean metal look is the goal. The same principle applies to pins, which is why how die-struck pins are made is covered separately.
Materials and Finishes
Material choice is part of the process decision. Zinc alloy is the most common and cost-effective material for die-cast medals, challenge coins, badges, and 3D designs. Brass is softer, holds good detail, and gives a premium feel for badges, high-end medals, and pins. Copper suits traditional cloisonné and hard enamel products. Iron is economical for stamping or simple die-cast designs and large-volume basic products. Stainless steel is corrosion-resistant with a clean, premium look; aluminium is lightweight; pewter takes rich detail for delicate badges; and bronze has a traditional, collectible feel for challenge coins and commemorative pieces.
Both processes work well with a wide range of plating and enamel options, so die-struck and die-cast medals can be finished in gold, silver, antique gold, antique silver, and custom colors.
Ribbons and Presentation for Medals
The ribbon of a sport medal is usually printed with the competition name or logo. Depending on your design, the ribbon can be silkscreen printed or sublimation printed. There are two common ways to secure the ribbon to the medal: when the hanging hole is a round loop, a V-neck ribbon is usually recommended; when the medal has a slot top, the ribbon is passed through and sewn in a line to keep it stable.
Production Timeline and Ordering
Most custom medal orders are completed in about 10–15 business days after the artwork, payment, and final order details are confirmed. Lead time depends on design complexity — simple engraving versus 3D relief — as well as order quantity, process, special effects, packaging, and shipping method. A digital proof is normally returned in around one business day once the details are complete.
Because both processes start from the same artwork, you do not have to decide alone. Send your design and we will recommend the most suitable process and material, with factory-direct pricing and digital proof support on low MOQ from 50 pcs, so small events and clubs are not priced out.
Conclusion
Both processes produce high-quality products. The best choice depends on your artwork, quantity, and budget. Send your design to a custom medal manufacturer and ask which process they recommend.
Next: a price, a date, and a proof
Tell us the quantity, the size and the date you need it. You get a unit price with tooling listed separately, a production date, and a digital proof to approve before the tool is cut.